Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe: Baked Mac & Cheese

This Bajan macaroni pie recipe takes the ultimate comfort food, baked mac and cheese, to another level. Loaded with spices such as paprika, thyme, chilli and mustard and baked in the oven with a golden crust of cheese and breadcrumbs, it doesn’t get more comforting than this.

Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe | Vegetarian Bajan Cuisine

Introduction to Barbados

We’ve cooked our way through two Caribbean countries, and now we are already on to our third… Barbados! If you’ve read our posts from Antigua or the Bahamas, you may be able to deduce that Caribbean cuisine hasn’t had us overly enthused thus far. Neither archipelago have proffered many vegetarian-friendly dishes.  However, we had heard that Barbados is supposedly the culinary capital of the Caribbean, so we went in with open minds and hungry bellies.

Like many countries in the Caribbean, Barbadian cuisine (also known as Bajan) is a mash-up of cultures. Prominent influences include African, Portuguese, Indian and British. Unsurprisingly, this Caribbean island is most known for its seafood, meaning most typical Barbadian dishes revolve around fish. A typical meal consists of meat or fish served with sides and sauces. Apparently, they really love their condiments in Barbados, so it is not uncommon to be served a multitude of sauces with a meal. In terms of flavour, Barbados uses strong, spicy combinations such as thyme, marjoram, chilli, garlic and lime juice.

When it comes to vegetables, asparagus and okra are grown in abundance so feature in a lot of recipes. If you are visiting Barbados, supposedly everywhere is vegetarian friendly. However, similar to the other Caribbean nations we have cooked from, there aren’t a huge number of typical dishes that don’t include meat.

Popular Bajan Dishes

  • Coucou–  The vegetarian part of the national dish of Barbados, coucou is made using cornmeal grain and fresh okra, and often comes topped with tomatoes, onions and peppers.
  • Cutters– Essentially cutters are the Barbadian version of a sandwich, served on their traditional salt bread and served Bajan pepper sauce and assorted fillings such as egg and cheese
  • Macaroni Pie- A decadent take on mac and cheese that uses spices, ketchup, mustard and evaporated milk for extra flavour then baked in the oven
  • Conkies– A traditional dessert made of sweet potato, pumpkin, cornmeal and coconut wrapped in banana leaves, usually served during the island’s annual independence celebrations in November.
  • Bajan Black Cake– Similar to Christmas plum pudding, this dense cake is filled with dried fruit. However, in this Bajan dessert, brandy is replaced rum.
Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe | Vegetarian Bajan Cuisine

Making baked mac & cheese (Bajan macaroni pie)

Believe it or not, one the most popular foods to eat in Barbados is macaroni pie. In fact, many people consider it to be the unofficial national dish of the country. To be honest, this is not exactly the kind of dish we expected to find in the Caribbean. Then again, given the proximity to the USA, it kind of makes sense that this a version of this typical American dish has found its way down.

That being said, we definitely aren’t complaining.  We love a good mac and cheese (who doesn’t?), and we love variations of a classic dish. After the roaring success, we had with making Austrian Style Mac & Cheese (Käsespätzle) we were excited to give macaroni pie a go. Plus, given the limited vegetarian offerings of Barbadian cuisine, this seemed like a good option to run with.

Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe | Vegetarian Bajan Cuisine

What is macaroni pie?

Macaroni pie is essentially a Barbadian take on baked mac and cheese. However, there are a few key differences between the two.  The first difference is the texture. Mac and cheese tends to include a creamy, liquid sauce, while macaroni pie is baked in the oven and comes out a lot firmer. The second difference is the flavour profile. Unlike mac and cheese, which is a notoriously mild dish, Barbadian macaroni pie has a bit more kick to it. Spices such as paprika and thyme are included in the mixture, and chilli peppers are also commonly added for extra heat. The third difference is the variations ingredients used. Instead of normal milk, macaroni pie is made using evaporated milk to produce a thick, creamy texture. Other ingredients that are often added include mustard and ketchup.

We really enjoyed making and consuming this macaroni pie. It turned out to be super creamy on the inside, crunchy and golden on top, and had lots of interesting flavour going on throughout. Ours didn’t turn out quite as firm as the ones we had seen pictures of, but we preferred a slightly softer texture. The only qualm we had with our macaroni pie was that we made too much pasta and not enough sauce. We’ve adapted the recipe below to make sure the ratio of pasta and sauce is sufficient!

How to make baked mac & cheese (macaroni pie)

  1. Preheat oven and cook macaroni according to packet
  2. Sauté onion, garlic and all the spices together then pour over cooked macaroni
  3. Combine eggs, milk, mustard, salt and pepper in bowl and pour over macaroni along with half the cheese
  4. Transfer to casserole dish, top with more cheese, bake for 35 minutes and allow to cool slightly before serving. Easy as (macaroni) pie.
Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe | Vegetarian Bajan Cuisine

Ingredients notes for macaroni pie

  • Cheese– For our macaroni pie recipe, we used a mix of mozzarella and cheddar cheese. Mozzarella works well for its melty texture and cheddar is great for flavour. However, feel free to use a mix of whatever cheese you wish.
  • Chilli- If you like spice, we’d recommend using a fresh chilli (jalapenos work well) as well as chilli powder. However, do omit if you are spice-sensitive.
  • Evaporated milk- Evaporated milk is one of the key ingredients that differentiates macaroni pie from regular mac and cheese. Its thick, creamy texture helps 
  • Breadcrumbs– To add a delicious golden crust to our macaroni pie, we added a layer of panko breadcrumbs in with the final layer of cheese. This is optional, but recommended (and you can use any type of breadcrumb you have on hand).
Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe | Vegetarian Bajan Cuisine

Serving suggestions for the baked mac and cheese (macaroni pie)

This baked macaroni pie works wonderfully as a stand-alone vegetarian meal, otherwise you can have it as a side to another dish. We served ours with a nice fresh salad to balance out the rich, creaminess of the dish, but you can really serve this with whatever your heart desires!

Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe | Vegetarian Bajan Cuisine

Bajan Macaroni Pie Recipe - Baked Mac and Cheese

Yield: 4-6
Prep Time: 20 minutes
Cook Time: 35 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes

This Bajan macaroni pie recipe takes the ultimate comfort food, mac and cheese, to another level. Loaded with spices and baked in the oven with a golden crust of cheese and breadcrumbs, it doesn’t get much better than this macaroni recipe.

Ingredients

  • 500 g elbow macaroni
  • 2 tbsp butter
  • 1 onion (finely diced)
  • 4 cloves of garlic (minced)
  • 1 chilli (diced)
  • 1 tsp paprika
  • 1 tsp thyme
  • 1/2 tsp chilli powder
  • 2 eggs. beaten
  • 2 cups evaporated milk
  • 1 tbsp Dijon mustard
  • Salt & pepper (to taste )
  • 1 cup mozzarella (grated)
  • 2 cups cheddar cheese (grated)
  • 1/3 cup breadcrumbs

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 175˚C (350˚F) and grease a large casserole dish.
  2. Cook macaroni according to the directions on the packet. Once cooked, drain and place back in pot to cool.
  3. Heat a large frying pan over medium heat and add 2 tablespoons of butter to pan. Add in diced onion and sauté until caramelised, around 7 minutes. Add in minced garlic, diced chilli, paprika, thyme and chilli powder and sauté for another minute. Pour mixture from frying pan over cooked macaroni and stir to combine.
  4. In a large bowl, beat eggs. Add evaporated milk, mustard and salt and pepper to taste. Pour egg mixture over macaroni and stir to combine. Stir in 1/2 cup mozzarella and 1 cup cheddar cheese. Tip macaroni mixture into greased casserole tin. Top with remaining cheese and breadcrumbs.
  5. Cover with foil and bake for 35 minutes or until pie is firm. At the 25 minute mark, take off foil and allow to brown on top.

Did you make this recipe?

Leave a comment & review above or share a photo on Instagram tagging @polkadotpassport so I can reshare your creations!

More comfort food dishes to try:

Liked this Bajan macaroni pie recipe? Pin it for later!

A recipe for Bajan macaroni pie from Barbados
Nicola Easterby Bio Image

HEY THERE, I'M NICOLA!

I am on a mission to discover the BEST destinations & dishes from around the world. In fact, I’ve visited 54 countries and cooked 196 cuisines in this very pursuit. Whether it’s hopping on a plane or into the kitchen, come join the adventure!

CURRENTLY TRENDING:

Biscoff Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Biscoff Carrot Cake Cheesecake

This is a dessert mash-up made in heaven. Moist spiced carrot cake is layered with a creamy biscoff no-bake cheesecake then topped off with more biscoff spread, lotus biscuits and pecans. You know those things you eat and dream about years later? The carrot cake...

The BEST 23 things to do in the Catlins NZ in 2022

The BEST 23 things to do in the Catlins NZ in 2022

The ultimate guide to visiting the Catlins in 2022, including the best things to do, where to stay and how to get around the South Island of New Zealand's most overlooked destination. The Catlins is one of New Zealand’s most underrated gems. The region, located in the...

The TOP 6 North Island Glamping Spots in New Zealand

The TOP 6 North Island Glamping Spots in New Zealand

If you are looking for a spectacular place to go Glamping on the North Island of New Zealand, look no further. These 6 NZ glamping spots each feature luxurious safari tents, idyllic outdoor baths, and jaw-dropping views. With its endless lush countryside, unique...

READ NEXT:

Healthy Vegan Anzac Biscuits Recipe

Healthy Vegan Anzac Biscuits Recipe

These anzac biscuits, made with rolled oats, desiccated coconut and golden syrup, are soft, chewy and so delicious. I promise you wouldn't know that they are a healthier vegan and gluten-free take on the typical anzac biscuit! Every year on April 25th, we celebrated...

read more
Biscoff Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Biscoff Carrot Cake Cheesecake

This is a dessert mash-up made in heaven. Moist spiced carrot cake is layered with a creamy biscoff no-bake cheesecake then topped off with more biscoff spread, lotus biscuits and pecans. You know those things you eat and dream about years later? The carrot cake...

read more
Tostada de Frijoles Recipe from Guatemala

Tostada de Frijoles Recipe from Guatemala

These tostada de frijoles have got to be one Guatemala's tastiest vegetarian recipes. Corn tortillas are fried till crisp, then topped with hearty refried bean mix, tangy cabbage slaw, fresh slices of avocado, tomato and chilli. Overview of Guatemala Guatemala holds a...

read more

READ NEXT:

Los Angeles Itinerary: How to Spend 2 Days in LA

Los Angeles Itinerary: How to Spend 2 Days in LA

Visiting L.A on a time crunch? Follow my ultimate Los Angeles itinerary to ensure you make the most of 2 days in la la land! I must admit, the first time I visited Los Angeles, I was not very enamoured by the city of stars. Getting around was difficult, everywhere I...

read more
Healthy Vegan Anzac Biscuits Recipe

Healthy Vegan Anzac Biscuits Recipe

These anzac biscuits, made with rolled oats, desiccated coconut and golden syrup, are soft, chewy and so delicious. I promise you wouldn't know that they are a healthier vegan and gluten-free take on the typical anzac biscuit! Every year on April 25th, we celebrated...

read more
Biscoff Carrot Cake Cheesecake

Biscoff Carrot Cake Cheesecake

This is a dessert mash-up made in heaven. Moist spiced carrot cake is layered with a creamy biscoff no-bake cheesecake then topped off with more biscoff spread, lotus biscuits and pecans. You know those things you eat and dream about years later? The carrot cake...

read more
Skip to Recipe